online edition

The Student Newspaper of Hopkins School

    • A father and his son embrace after eventually being reunited.

Moral Crisis at the Border

Connor Hartigan ’19 Op/Ed Editor
I have to give the Trump administration credit for one impressive achievement.
They always manage, like world-class limbo dancers, to crawl under whatever bar of expectations I have set for them, no matter how low. Their immorality endows them with the endless ability to sink lower into the morass of malice, making concepts like “kindness” and “empathy”, to say nothing of “rationality,” seem positively quaint.

Since the end of May, when the story of family separation and “zero tolerance” immigration policy broke nationally, I’ve spent much of my time following the news from our southwestern border. In a distressing change from the stances of previous administrations, the Trump administration declared that it would launch full criminal proceedings against every person who entered the U.S. without proper authorization and detain them for the duration of their cases. No “catch-and-release” and certainly no amnesty. Even worse, families who crossed the border together were forcibly separated, and their children were scattered to unfamiliar detention facilities, housed with complete strangers in horrifying conditions.

You may remember the most salient images: the calls for “security” and “toughness” from rightwing circles; the recordings of little children begging to see their parents; the photo of the wailing little girl, overcome by abject terror; the mural in a holding center in Brownsville, Texas, bearing a giant portrait of Trump, with the chillingly militaristic phrase “sometimes by losing a battle you find a way to win the war.”

These places are not “summer camps,” as one desperate Immigration and Customs Enforcement official claimed. ICE agents abused a 6-year-old girl in a facility in Arizona, subsequently forcing her to sign a statement accepting that it was her responsibility to avoid potential threats. When doctors are actually allowed into detention facilities,  they return with reports that the children are bearing respiratory diseases, infected with lice, and traumatized.

Make no mistake: the blame for this inhumane horror lies at Trump’s feet, despite nonsensical attempts by the conservative fringes to pin responsibility on President Obama, who has been out of office for twenty months. “Zero tolerance” is Trump’s moral disaster.

This whole presidency has been terrible — from Trump’s unnatural warmth with Russia and probable obstruction of justice in the case of election interference, to his moves to gut the EPA and the National Park system, to his assault on the free press — but, from a moral standpoint, this is the worst thing he’s done. The administration is even flouting constitutional checks and balances in order to perpetuate its policy. Hundreds of children remain separated from their families, more than a month after a court deadline to reunite them expired.

Remember when we were at rock bottom? We’re straining our eyes to look up there now.

If we cannot agree that abusing vulnerable children in this way is wrong, where is the soul of our nation?
Editor in Chief 
Eleanor Doolittle

Managing Editor 
Sarah Roberts 

Zoe Kim 
Anushree Vashist
Juan Lopez
Orly Baum
Katherine Takoudes 
Julia Kosinski
Anjali Subramanian
Emmett Dowd
Lily Meyers 
Ella Zuse
Zach Williamson 

Saira Munshani
Sophie Sonnenfeld
Kallie Schmeisser

Veronica Yarovinsky
Teddy Glover
Abby Regan
Maeve Stauff
Izzy Lopez-Kalapir

Arthur Masiukiewicz 

Arushi Srivastava
Nick Hughes

Business Managers
Sophia Fitzsimonds
Sophia Cerroni 

Faculty Advisers
Jenny Nicolelli
Elizabeth Gleason
Sorrel Westbrook-Wilson 
The Razor's Edge reflects the opinion of 4/5 of the editorial board and will not be signed. The Razor welcomes letters to the editor but reserves the right to decide which letters to publish, and to edit letters for space reasons. Unsigned letters will not be published, but names may be withheld on request. Letters are subject to the same libel laws as articles. The views expressed in letters are not necessarily those of the editorial board.
The Razor,
 an open forum publication, is published monthly during the school year by students of: 
Hopkins School
986 Forest Road
New Haven, CT 06515

Phone: 203.397.1001 x271